Tuesday, January 31, 2012

Discuss:
The CRAFT model – Contact, Research, Action, Feedback and Teaching-- is described in the text using several examples of art based program implementation. Discuss what you learned from these examples and how you would apply these strategies when entering a community like Mart to work on your project.

By looking at the  examples from the book I saw a critical difference between the program leaders and myself. The vast majority of them were already part of the community that they decided to serve, unlike me. So I took note on those who placed themselves into the community and saw a pattern of communication, and more importantly listening as a main tool for research. If you are not a part of the community that you are serving it is very important to let the community decide what is needed rather than implementing what you think needs to be done. I saw this in a few stories that the community needed to hold the reins of the "action" process while the leader made contact and helped to formulate their ideas into action. Giving up control can be difficult, but for the success of a project as well as the acceptance in the community and the sustainability it needs to be done strategically.

Also within the sustainability of a project I think the "teaching" role is most important. To give Mart the power to control their own community development through art would be extraordinary. They would have built-in creative resources that could be accessible for the community and the empowerment that brings with community resources.

On page 27, the Tip is to “be as honest and open with yourself as you are asking others to be.” The topic questions posed ask you about barriers to open communication, assumptions about a community and its residents, and common goals you and the people in the community share. How have the program examples in the text helped you to think about these issues?
Relate this to your self-assessment exercise that is due on 1/31.

Being honest about your intentions within the community and being honest about who you are and where you come from is very important.  People will find connections to you and relate to you can only open opportunities to share. Going into a community as a stranger and trying to change things can cause a source of contempt within the community. Think of someone coming into your home and changing things around without asking your imput, it is invading personal territory and would be considered threatening. What if we then had someone we knew come over and they asked us to consider a change in our house, we would because we know that person has only good intentions and could have a point. We will not be the exact same as the people in Mart, we have different backgrounds, different knowledge sources, and different opinions but by opening up personal lines of communication we can start to understand what we can do for the each of the residents as well as the Mart community. 

2 comments:

  1. I really like the example you gave about someone coming into your home and changing things around. I never thought of it that way and now I can see exactly why some communities might not like the change "outsiders" implement in their neighborhood. Yes, it could be a great idea and could even benefit the community, but without first asking the community if that is what they want, it can be seen as overstepping boundaries and an insult to their town.

    ReplyDelete
  2. A few years ago, I was in a conversation with a girl from New Orleans, who was talking about the flood (yikes, no pun intended...) of people who'd swept in after Katrina to implement their own versions of "rebuilding" projects - she said it felt like living in a weird petrie dish where all these people (many or even most of them not from NOLA) were running experiments but not actually trusting the people who lived their to make their own decisions about the place where THEY lived, where THEY were the experts. I had never even considered it from that perspective before, and it gave me a lot to think about in terms of Katrina (and other!) "cleanup" or "rebuilding" projects...

    ReplyDelete